House Histories
                           Short Histories #2, Rebecca's Bungalow on Henzell Hill new
                           Short Histories #1, "Nyth-A-Deryn"
                           Cooroon - the Spinster Palace on Highgate Hill
                           Asgrove Time Capsule 
                           Ken's Sunnybank Farmhouse
                           Caroline's West End Cottage 
                           Discover the History of your House - the Clovelly Story
                           Discover the History of your House - from your Couch
     
                     History
                           Shorncliffe Ruins
                           Backyard Mangoes 
                           Bricks
                           Auchenflower Landowners - Part I, Arnold Wienholt
                           Auchenflower Landowners - Part II, Simon Munro

                     Renovations
                           Queensland House Designs, 1925 to 1959 
                           More Glass and Locks
                           Transom Window Lifts 
                           Purple and Green
                           Locks

                     Random Observations
                           A Peppercorn Rent Forever
                           Character Housing and the New Brisbane City Plan
                           Convict Made?
                           Call of the Toowong
                           Postcard from Sugar Country
                           An Unexpected Note
                           Lawn Medallion


Brisbane Open House, October 12-13


This is just a quick plug for the upcoming Open House 2013, when the good people of Brisbane will have a wonderful opportunity to visit and view 71 of our historically and architecturally most significant buildings. Vintage housing buffs such as yours truly are salivating over the "Heritage Jewels" subsection, agonizing over how many sites can be covered in two days and which to leave for another year. The blockbuster list of historic sites includes:

56. Boggo Road Gaol
3. Brisbane Arcade
4. Brisbane City Hall
5. Brisbane Polo Club – Naldham House
26. Commissariat Store Museum
8. Customs House
58. Diamantina Health Care Museum
61. Howard Smith Wharves
11. MacArthur Museum
12. Masonic Memorial Temple
14. National Australia Bank
63. Newstead House
27. Old Government House
51. Old Museum Brisbane
28. Parliament House
40. Queensland Maritime Museum
17. Shingle Inn City Hall
54. Spring Hill Baths
22. Tara House – Irish Club
23. Tattersall's Club
30. Treasury Casino & Hotel
71. UQ – Michie Building – Anthropology and RD Milns Antiquities Museums
69. UQ – The Great Court
25. Windmill Tower

For full details check the Brisbane Open House homepage at: http://brisbaneopenhouse.com.au. Please note that some of the buildings require prior booking.

As for this blog, activity has been subdued lately due to some private and professional distractions but I have several interesting houses in the research pipeline and a few related topics to cover over the coming months. The blog is a long-term project and I'm very grateful for the feedback and leads that I have received so far.

I hope to see you at the open house weekend!

Short Histories #2, Rebecca's Bungalow on Henzell Hill



Rebecca pinged me with a question regarding her recently acquired 1920's house in Greenslopes. The property came with a 120 meter access road to the back and she was keen to understand the original reason for this unusual and quite substantial appendage.

The house itself is a roomy chamferboard bungalow, typical for its age and high-set on the southern slope of Henzell hill. The original layout comprised four bedrooms, separate living spaces and a large, U-shaped veranda which was later built in. The old lady was in a sorry state but is now undergoing a complete rejuvenation including removal of some unwanted modifications (and materials) from the 50s and 60s. All of the below pictures were taken pre-renovation, but perhaps we'll return one day to do a glamour shot of the final product. I have no doubt that it will turn out great.

Street facing facade with entry stairs and porch (left), and hooded 
rear window (right)

Kitchen and bedroom. The original (and widespread) pastel pink and green 
scheme continues from the veranda throughout the interior.

The European history of this part of Greenslopes begins in the 1860s when Robert George Rowton, a  builder hailing from Coventry in England, and Thomas Mulhall King, the Colonial Treasurer and later Auditor General of Queensland, each bought a portion of adjacent lands covering 60 or so acres with excellent views across the river plains to the north and west. Rebecca's land spans the mutual boundary and incorporates both of these original land grants.

R. G. Rowton's and T. M King's portions of land on
Henzell Hill. Click to enlarge.

By the 1880s the land was owned by the land agent and speculator Frederick Henzell, who gave name to the hill, and in 1904 it passed to Edward James Curd, a schoolmaster living in nearby Thomas Street. By late 1925 the southern section had been subdivided into the Curd's Hill Estate comprising 23 lots of twenty to sixty perches each. The blocks were supplied with electric light and water and were located only a street away from the Greenslopes tram terminus -  a very attractive spot for suburban development. The Brisbane Courier reported that all allotments sold under "keen competition and spirited bidding" for sums ranging from £70 to £360.

1925 estate sales brochure for "Curd's Hill". Click to enlarge.

The buyer of the biggest block of land was John Reid Still, an engine driver (synonymous with machinery operator), his wife Ivy and two daughters Gladys and Vivian. The house was probably built soon after the purchase and in 1929 the social column reported a party at the Still's residence, where:

"The spacious verandas, where dancing took place, were decorated with multi-coloured
lights, streamers and balloons, and supper was served in the veranda lounge at tables 
beautified with tall crystal vases of golden snapdragons"

A surveyor plan from the 1930s reveal some of the original features of the house, including a front yard tennis court and the usual dunny and water tank to the back. Many of the neighbouring properties also had tennis courts -  a sign of the comfortable, middle class neighbourhood that it had become.

1930s surveyor plan of the house and land, including tennis
court and outbuildings. Click to enlarge.

The Stills sold out in 1942 and the girls left home. Vivian married an American soldier in Melbourne in 1945, but beyond that I haven't been able to trace the fate of these two ladies, which is a shame as their descendants may have photos and information about the early days of the house.

So what about that long easement to the back? Well - if you look closely at the 1925 estate sales brochure you will see that the access road was already planned as part of the subdivision design. Rebecca's property, being the largest plot of land and located at the end of the easement, became the legal owner of the road and other properties along its path were granted unrestricted access. The reason was probably pure convenience - providing easy access for deliveries and the unglamorous visitations of the "nightman". The Council records show that the northern part of the hill was sewered by the 1940's but inhabitants of the southern slope were confined to using their backyard dunnies well into the 1950's.

Good luck Rebecca and family with your renovations, and let us know when we can come back to take a second look at your charming, fully restored home.

The 150 meter easement - part drivable, part 
"secret garden". Click to enlarge.

Key sources:
- Deed of Grant and historical Title Deeds for the property, sourced from Queensland DNRM
- TROVE historical newspaper archives
- Genealogy.com, for family trees, census records and electoral rolls
- Post office directories from the 1870's through to the 1940's
- Pugh's Almanac, 1859-1927
- Queensland Government Gazettes, 1836-1900
- Queensland Education Gazettes, 1899-1959
- Aerial photography, BCC PDOnline
- Miscellaneous texts on Queensland history
- Parish and miscellaneous maps, courtesy of the Queensland State and BCC Archives
- Brisbane House Styles 1880-1940, a Guide to the Affordable House, J. G. Rechner
 - Brisbane 1859-1959 : a history of local government, Greenwood and Laverty

Short Histories #1, "Nyth-A Deryn"

Nyth-A-Deryn as seen from Empress Terrace, photo courtesy of Space property agents

Michelle pinged me with a request to investigate "Nyth-A-Deryn", her house in Bardon which was for sale and scheduled for auction. The remarkable features of this home are plain to see in the photos below, including the extravagant Art Deco design of the main living areas with contemporary details continuing throughout the original parts of the house. Michelle was curious to see if we could track down the architect or builder before it passed to the next owner.

Viewed from the street, the house is a transverse gable which has been expanded with a veranda (to the left in the title picture) and sympathetically built underneath. The flat-roofed vestibule and bold design of the half-timbered gable infills are unusual features of what is otherwise a fairly typical 1930's home. But any preconceptions of normalcy are blown away as we step inside. Let's start with the drawing room, featuring rails, frames and a monumental room divider in chunky, gleaming silky oak. Also note the patterned hardwood floor and the mini-dome and fine detailing of the plaster ceiling.

The drawing room, photo courtsey of  Space Property Agents
Next the dining room, with veneered wall paneling and ceiling coffers. The fan-patterned inlays, contrasting use of timbers and strong vertical elements ooze of the Art Deco movement that reached Australia in the 1930s. There's an enormous amount of detail in this interior, more than we can cover in a short post. For example - the semi-hidden, spring-loaded pivot door to the kitchen is more reminiscent of a restaurant than a suburban home.

The dining room, photo courtesy of Space Property Agents
So what's the story behind this treasure of 30's interior design? Well - in this case let's skip the (not so ancient) history of Bardon and the original owners of the portion of land, and go directly to the historical title deeds for Nyth-A-Deryn.

In 1935 a 1,036 sqm plot of land was purchased by Charles William Hunt, a carpenter previously listed as living in Mt Isa. Shortly thereafter he applied for a mortgage to the State Advances Corporation, the government body charged with " the granting of loans to enable persons of limited income to erect... suitable homes for themselves, with a comparatively small contribution by them towards the proposition, with easy terms of repayment, and with a low rate of interest".

The Corporation issued mortgages to workers and artisans below a yearly income threshold, who already owned a suitable plot of land and wanted to build a house for primary residence. In many cases the construction works were tendered by the corporation on behalf of its clients, and lo and behold, a search of the news archives yields 20+ reports of Charles Hunt successfully bidding for projects in Bardon, Ashgrove and surrounding suburbs between 1934 to 1939.

Charles Hunt is contracted to build an Ashgrove
worker's dwellings, 1934. Click to enlarge.

So - despite the opulence of Nyth-A-Deryn, Charles Hunt was a humble carpenter and local builder of homes for the government worker's dwelling corporation, and he financed his own home under the same scheme. I haven't found any records of a tender so it is likely that he struck a deal with the Commission to build it himself. The basic design was probably from a standard pattern but again I haven't been able to find it in the published catalogues. As for the interior fitout and high-spec features, this was well beyond the scope of government funding but he probably made good use of his industry contacts or perhaps did some of the work himself. In any case, the quality of the workmanship is beyond doubt and this home will delight owners and dazzle visitors for many, many decades to come.

Otherwise the historical records yield very little information on Charles, as is often the case with working-class owners. He married Ethel May Robertson in 1936, the same year that the house was built, and stayed there until 1992 when he was well into his 80s. I've found no indication that the couple had children, and other than a publicized drunken driver charge in 1940 the couple appeared to have lived a private life. Charles' carpentry business was not listed in the commercial directories or in the press, at least not under his own name. The land was subdivided in 1965 and the Eastern portion developed as a separate property, as indicated in the below 1938 map overlay on a contemporary aerial photo.

Survey map ca 1938, showing the original plot of land pre-subdivision and
later house extensions. Click to enlarge.

As for the name, "Nyth-A-Deryn" translates to "Birds Nest" in Welsh and it is possible that it has its origins in Ethel's Welsh-ringing surname, but that's pure conjecture.

Thanks to Michelle for the opportunity to research her house, and congratulations to the new owners of this very unique suburban home.


Key sources:
- Deed of Grant and historical Title Deeds for the property, sourced from Queensland DNRM
- TROVE historical newspaper archives
- Genealogy.com, for family trees, census records and electoral rolls
- Post office directories from the 1870's through to the 1940's
- Queensland Police Gazette, 1864-1945
- Pugh's Almanac, 1859-1927
- Queensland Government Gazettes, 1836-1900
- Aerial photography, BCC PDOnline
- Miscellaneous texts on Queensland history
- Parish and miscellaneous maps, courtesy of the Queensland State and BCC Archives
- Brisbane House Styles 1880-1940, a Guide to the Affordable House, J. G. Rechner

Cooroon - the Spinster Palace on Highgate Hill


The house "Cooroon", built in 1927, sits high on the western ridge of Highgate Hill, with views stretching from Tambourine Mountain to Mount Coot-tha and the St Lucia reach of Brisbane river below. In many ways it's a typical design of its time, although it was built as an unusually spacious two-floor residence and incorporates some peculiar materials. The name is onomatopoeic and hints to the pigeons that used to perch on the roof, but also to the nickname of one of the two spinster sisters from the notable Waugh Family that built the house and lived in it for nearly forty years.

In this post we will take a brief look at the history of the Highgate Hill suburb, the colorful colonial owners of the land, the sequence of suburban subdivision and development, the house itself and the Wagh family. Again I have called on the generous help of my blogging companion Elizabeth from the Walk Among the Homes blog, to capture Cooroon as we peek inside.

Highgate Hill in Colonial Days

At the time of European settlement Highgate Hill was covered in a forest of gums, ironbark and native pines, with rocky outcrops and seasonal creeks meandering down to the swampy riverside jungles of South Brisbane. The hill was called "Bennung-urrung", the name for the resident frilled dragon, by the people of the Jaggara tribe.

The area was raided for timber to supply the emerging riverside settlements and following surveys in 1855 and 1857 it was quickly divided into portions and sold to private owners. By the late 1860's a  few residences were scattered across the hill, mainly occupied by professionals and public servants as public transport for the industrial classes was still many years away. Travel to the city was by a dirt track that was later to become Gladstone Road.

First landowners of Highgate Hill; Nehamiah Bartley (left portion, granted 1860)
and Thomas Blacket Stephens (right portion, granted 1861). Click to enlarge.

In 1892 the renowned colonial business man Nehemiah Bartley (1830-1894) wrote:

"Inside the city boundary, the greatest elevation is 300 feet, at "Highgate Hill", and, 
nowhere within the municipal boundaries of London, Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide 
or Hobart, is there so high a one as this, which fact gives a fair idea of the hill and dale
in the capital of Queesland"

Nehemiah was very familiar with the location as he had bought a sizable portion of land on the western slopes in 1860. Along with his many business and political interests he can be described as a collector of hilltops, and his collection included lands on Ascot Hill (still called "Bartley's Hill), Eildon Hill, Hamilton Hill, Spring Hill and others. He built a peculiar house on Hamilton Hill which came to be known as "Bartley's Folly" but had to abandon it due to harassment by "snakes, centipedes and blacks". The bank panic of 1866 saw the end of his property fortunes and he later became one of early Brisbane's originals, often seen riding down Queen St on an old mare wearing a pith helmet. But Nehemiah is also immortalized as an important chronicler of Queensland's early history, through his books Opals and Agates and Australian Pioneers and Reminiscences.

Nehemiah Bartley (left) and Thomas Blacket Stephens (right), original
owners of the Cooroon land

The second portion of land in the Cooroon neighborhood was  purchased by Thomas Blacket Stephens (1819-1877) -  yet another entrepreneur and politician, and from 1862 also Brisbane's second mayor. Stephens was a member of the primitive baptist congregation of South Brisbane and his moral and political agenda prompted him to buy the Brisbane Courier, which he converted to a large-format, daily paper. Legend has it that he caused a sensation on Highgate Hill when he claimed to have found traces of gold on his land and started digging a shaft near the current intersection of Gladstone Road and Gloucester St, which he abandoned at a depth of 50 ft without having struck the imagined reef. In time he went on to occupy a range of prominent positions including Colonial Treasurer, Postmaster General and Member of Parliament for South Brisbane. By all accounts he was an outstanding citizen of his time.

The origin of the name Highgate Hill eludes us but we find it for the first time in the Brisbane Courier in 1864, in a land sale advertisement for the "Highgate Hill Estate" which comprised a large area of land along the western slopes between Dornoch Terrace and the River. One source mentions the Scottish immigrant George Wilson and his family, who arrived in Brisbane in 1864 and settled on top of the hill, as the originators, but this seems unlikely as the name was published that same year.

Another pioneering homesteader and possibly the first resident of the hill was John Henry Trimble Senior, who immigrated with his young family from Southampton in 1864 and took up employment as 'landing waiter", or dockside customs officer, with the Queensland customs department. From 1867 we have a birth notice with his address listed as Trimble St, which is now Chermside Street. John stayed with his modest profession and house for the rest of his life but his two sons came to play a key role in the future development of the neighborhood, as we shall see.

Speculation and Subdivision, 1889 -1926

By 1889 the bulk of Bartley's and Stephen's former lands on the southern slopes had been incorporated in to the Hazelwood Estate, covering the area between the river, Dauphin Road, Dornoch Terrace and Gladstone Road. The name was taken from the Hazelwood homestead which was located on the crest of the hill by the nascent Gladstone Road, but which had been demolished in 1888 to make room for the new service water reservoir. Up to that point, water had been carried by the locals from a spring on Boundary street near the current Boundary Hotel. The reservoir boosted the supply to South Brisbane and became an enabler for further residential development on the hill.

Hazelwood Estate in 1891. Click to enlarge 

Sale of the Hazelwood started 1889 and continued throughout the 1890's. The inaugural auction was managed by the Trimble Brothers and was a heavily promoted affair, with large Brisbane Courier advertisements stating (emphasis retained):

"The most important land sale in the city.. on top of the HIGHGATE HILL which is also 
known as the WICKHAM TERRACE OF SOUTH BRISBANE, commanding 
extensive scenery embracing MORETON ISLAND, the great DIVIDING RANGE, 
CUNNINGHAM'S GAP, Little Liverpool Range, Glass House Mountains, Taylor's Range 
and the SERPENTINE WINDINGS OF THE BRISBANE RIVER forming ONE GRAND 
PANORAMA WHICH CANNOT BE SURPASSED"

The views from the top of the hill are indeed spectacular, and would have been even more so before the grazed crest and slopes were dressed in mature suburban gardens and trees. Also adding to the attraction of the new suburb was the horse-drawn omnibus service which by the 1880's departed to and from the city every ten minutes.

The Trimble Brother consisted of Alexander (1861-1932) and John Henry Junior (1865-1943), both sons of the settler John Henry Trimble. The boys were in their tender teens and early twenties when they ventured into business as fancy goods importers, operating from an office located in the long demolished Temple Buildings on the corner of Queen and George Streets. Their catalogue included ornamental items, gold and silver but increasingly turned to tobacco and in particular a large assortment of Havana cigars. From 1887 the advertisements changed tone and came to include commission agencies for property, land and mining.
Trimble Brothers advertisements in 1884 (left), 1887 (top right) and
1888 (bottom right). Click to enlarge.

These were the years of the great 19th century land and mining boom and it captured the enterprising siblings. In the late 1880's they went all-in, advertising in the Brisbane Courier for £100,000 to lend on mortgages of city and suburban properties. They also invested their own capital in land, including four adjacent lots on Highgate Hill, two of which now comprise the Cooroon property.

Trimble land holdings on Highgate Hill, 1891. The two lots on the right
now comprise the Cooroon plot of land. Click to enlarge.

The auction in 1889 coincided with the peak of the property bubble and land prices took a dive as the country descended into the 1890's depression. The Trimble brothers shared the fate of many other speculators and were declared insolvent in 1893. We don't know the full extent of their land holdings but their triple exposure to real estate as auctioneers, property owners and financiers must have devastated any capital accumulated during the boom years.

The Brothers retained the four lots on the hill until 1904 when they were sold for the sum of £175 to John Bell (1830-1911), a respected Scottish immigrant and long-standing Brisbane merchant who lived with his family in the nearby Beaconsfield Street. John died in 1911 and the land passed to his wife Margaret who held it until 1926.

The merchant John Bell

There are no indications that the Cooroon land was ever the site of a house prior to 1926. A cattle brand from the 1880s suggests that the Trimble brothers used their undeveloped land assets for pasture, which was often the case.

Cooroon and the Waugh Family, 1926-1963

John Neill Waugh (1818-1900) received his medical doctor's degree from the University of St Andrews in 1856 and that same year a license from the Apothecaries Society. After a few year's practice in London he was employed as a ship's surgeon with the East India Company which took him to India, Africa and finally Australia before settling down in Brisbane in 1858. He traveled back to England in to marry his cousin Margaret Pasfield in 1863, and returned to Brisbane with his bride to settle in a cottage on Herschel St on North Quay.

John Neill Waugh, photo courtesy
of Ancestry.com

The historical records yield plenty of information on John and his many business dealings, interests and civic engagements. First and foremost he continued his career as a medical doctor, practicing from his cottage on North Bank for many decades, but he was also a very active in the ever controversial field of homeopathy. His interest in natural sciences led him to the Queensland Philosophical Society where a select group of intellectuals discussed "scientific subjects, with special reference to the natural history, climate, soil and agriculture of the colony of Queensland." John delivered lectures on spectroscopy and came to serve as councilor, curator and chairman of the organisation which laid the foundations for the Queensland Museum.

In 1868 the first large-scale sugar mill and plantation in Queensland, named Pearlwell, was established at the Tennyson side of the Oxley Creek and Brisbane River junction. The land was owned by John and he retained a majority stake in the company. Within a few years the cutting-edge, steam-powered mill produced a record one hundred tons of sugar in a single growing season and it became a model for centralised and mechanised sugar manufacturing. But John's interest in agricultural science went well beyond sugar and he remained heavily involved with the Queensland Acclimatisation Society throughout his life, and its efforts to expand the range of produce for Queensland's rural industries. In addition to all of the above he was a member of several masonic lodges, supporter of local charities and family father.

The couple had ten children but only three survived to adulthood and one, their son George Waugh, went on to raise a family. The two daughters Fanny Isabella "Dovie" and Naomi "Nono" remained in the family home on North Quay after the deaths of their father in 1900 and mother in 1905, and in 1926 they bought the plot of land on top of Highgate Hill. In 1928 they were listed in the newly built house Cooroon. Naomi is remembered by the family as a strong personality and tireless worker for charities, in particular the Queensland Braille Writer's Association where she transcribed many books and held positions as librarian and honorary secretary for over thirty years. Fanny Isabella suffered from health problems and lived a more retired life on the hill, but nevertheless featured regularly in the social columns in her sister's company.

The brother, George Waugh, became a solicitor and married Florence Ada Deuchar of the prominent pastoralist family from Glengallan house at Warwick. But Florence died only a few years later and George eventually joined his sisters at Cooroon. The last of the siblings passed away in 1960 and the house left the Waugh family in 1963.

A Look at Cooroon

Cooroon is a fairly typical suburban house design of the late 1920s, featuring a bungalow roof with projecting gables and a street-facing veranda which was later enclosed. A pattern from the 1927 War Services Commission catalogue offers a close match in both time and style - but, Cooroon is twice the size and was built as a two-level home with five bedrooms.

Street-facing veranda and frontispiece, which in the
standard one-level design would have adorned the entry staircase

Internally, one of the most striking features is the extent of dark stained pine deployed in the fretwork arch and half-height wall paneling of the dining and drawing rooms, and in doors, window frames and ceiling details throughout the house. The staircase makes extensive use of the timber on the stairs and walls. The well-preserved pine is untouched since the time of construction and has a wonderful rich-brown patina. Light plaster ceilings give a clean finish against the pine details.

Living Room

And here's another curiosity - all floors throughout the upper and lower level are made of Radiata or some other soft, non-native pine. I've found no records of exotic pine plantations in Australia that were harvested by the 1920s but it is possible that the timber was imported for the purpose or re-used from some other application. After nearly 90 years, the owners can still smell the resin in the wood whenever the house has been locked up for a while.

Internal views, including (from left) the built-in veranda, staircase,
pine flooring and ceiling details

A substantial, modern living area has been added to the back of the house but the original building is intact. The new part respects and compliments the old and vice versa - a great solution overall. More pictures of Cooroon can be found at the Walk Among the Homes blog.

Final Thoughts

House history research can be frustrating, particularly if you're congenitally curious and a bit stubborn. A narrative starting with a colonial era proto-suburb and ending with a house on a plot of land involves many interwoven strands of people, places, organisations, suburban and social histories and it is very, very easy to get sidetracked into some interesting but less relevant subplot to he main story. This was certainly the case for the Highgate Hill neighborhood and the characters involved in the history of Cooroon. Much of the research was left on the cutting board and many questions are outstanding. For example, there are some very old houses in the Trimble and Julia St neighborhood - did one of them belong to the purported first settler of the hill, John Trimble? Perhaps we can return to this suburb one day and pick up some of the loose strands.

My thanks to the current owners of Cooroon and to the Waugh family for sharing their house and family stories. As always we hope that this house is preserved as a family home, destined to raise many more generations of Brisbane vintage housing enthusiasts.




Researching house histories takes a fair bit of effort and to make the task less daunting I have omitted a detailed reference list. But as a rough guide, I have consulted the following key resources for this article:
- Personal communications with the Waugh family
- Deed of Grant and historical Title Deeds for the property, sourced from Queensland DNRM
Brief summary of the early and Aboriginal history of  the Highgate Hill etc., Ray Kerkhove, December 1985.
- History of Highgate Hill, J. K. Jarrott, 1997
- TROVE historical newspaper archives
- Genealogy.com, for family trees, census records, electoral rolls and passenger lists
- Post office directories from the 1870's through to the 1940's
- Pugh's Almanac, 1859-1927
- NSW and Queensland Government Gazettes, 1836-1900
- Aerial photography, BCC PDOnline
- Miscellaneous texts on Queensland history
- Parish and miscellaneous maps, courtesy of the Queensland State Archives
- Brisbane House Styles 1880-1940, a Guide to the Affordable House, J. G. Rechner

More Glass & Locks



Our latest farmstay on the Sunshine coast came with a very pleasant surprise - an apparently abandoned shed full of salvage windows, glass and miscellaneous hardware. So I snuck out early one morning with my camera to see if I could find anything of interest, which I did.

Let's start with a selection of rolled figured glass, a hallmark of vintage Queensland houses that we've looked at in a previous post. These panes are all original, rolled glass and many were imported from glassworks in the British Midlands. How do we know that they are original? Run your fingertips across the back and you'll feel the gentle undulations and imperfections of the manufacturing process. Reproduction figured glass is perfectly smooth and, I suppose, comparatively lifeless.

All of the below images are "clickable" to enlarge, but please excuse the average resolution of my smart-phone camera.

First out a louver window with (from the top) a clear pane of the ubiquitous "Arctic" glass followed by an amber pane of a Victorian-style medallion pattern that I have seen in houses dating back to the late 1880's, often in a bright red colour that went out of fashion when softer pastels arrived with the Art Noveau era. It is probably one of the oldest patterns commonly seen in the Brisbane suburbs. The bottom pane is a green "Venetian" variety.


 More of the medallion-style pattern, in clear glass.


The pretty "Muranese" pattern was manufactured by the Chance Brothers of Birmingham and came in a variety of colours, in small, medium and large pattern sizes. This window has medium patterns of purple, amber, green and clear glass.


A large pattern Muranese in green.


This pane has the Arctic pattern in cobalt blue, a bold and comparatively rare colour in our suburbs. A few of these panes in an external window is enough to dictate the colours of the rest of the house - it is that dominant.


Next up some made product made locally by Australian Window Glass Pty Ltd., from the late 20's and onward. Before this date all window glass, figured or not, was imported from overseas. These clear panes are of the "Pyramid" (left) and "Double Rolled Cathedral" (right) patterns. The bold geometry and prism-like effect of the Pyramid pattern goes well with architecture from the Art Deco era.


More Victorian medallions, in amber and purple.


I haven't come across this pattern before - basically a Granite-type pattern with transecting ribbons. Clearly a later and not particularly inspired design, probably by Australian Window Glass Pty Ltd.


And finally a wonderfully whimsical and naive "stars and swirls" pattern in green and purple. I found this glass in a homestead just North of the NSW border, built 1901. I haven't seen it anywhere else, and long may it remain in this historic property.



The shed had stacks of salvaged doors with original rim locks in varying states of decay. The most interesting is the second one, a pressed case rim lock marked "The Maryborough Special". Probably dating from the 1900s to 1930s I doubt that it was locally made - more likely manufactured and marked in the UK or US for a local retailer.



I'm always on the lookout for examples of antique architectural glass and hardware - if you have any interesting examples or information please let me know.

A Peppercorn Rent Forever


Apologies for the misleading title - I don't know of any property offered at the yearly rent of a peppercorn, at least not on this continent.

The term "Quit Rent of One Peppercorn for ever" shows up in colonial land grants, such as the above example from 1861. The inner suburbs of Brisbane were covered by a patchwork of hundreds of grants and the "peppercorn rent" clause appears in deeds until the late 1800s and possibly later. A few readers have asked me about this strange phrase so let's break it down.

Firstly, Peppercorns were used to establish a one-sided agreement under English common law. A contract couldn't be made for "something for nothing" and it had involve a two-way exchange of assets, however nominal, to be enforceable in court. A peppercorn is a hard asset and could therefore be used in agreements where one party surrendered specific rights for the benefit of the other party.

Land grants throughout the Empire also had Quit Rent clauses. The term harks back to medieval days when feudal land titles often had obligations to the ruling "Manor", such as provision of labor, horses, soldiers or hunting grounds. A yearly Quit Rent liberated the land holder from any such duties or "land taxes", whatever they may be.

So - the Peppercorn Quit Rent clause relieved the buyer of the land from any legacy obligations to the Crown, in exchange for an optional peppercorn payment per year. The system was abandoned in the UK in 1922 and probably also discontinued in Australia about that time. We can safely assume that no peppercorns were actually collected by the Crown or by the Queensland government, depriving them of yearly banquet of pasta carbonara, or perhaps steak au poivre.

Colonial land grant map, Western suburbs (click to enlarge). 
The crown was entitled to a yearly peppercorn "quit-rent" 
from each grant - if demanded. Click picture to enlarge.

Shorncliffe Ruins


If you've walked along the Shorncliffe headland from Moora Park you would have passed these melancholy remains on the beach, just to the right of the stone pier. They are easy to miss, but a closer look reveals a "ladies lavatory" sign rendered in concrete and miscellaneous Virginia-stamped brick rubble, scattered among the boulders and silty sand of the eroding cliff. I've always assumed that they must have belonged to a public building of some sort, related to the busy seaside trade in this little suburb in the early to mid 1900s.

After some research I can now confirm that we are looking at the remains of the demolished Moora Park Kiosk, which was perched on the top of the cliff between the two piers. The two-level brick and stucco structure was designed by the Brisbane city architect A. H. Foster, in the Hollywood-inspired Spanish Californian or "Mission" style that became so popular for public buildings and middle class residences in the 1920s. It was opened by Mayor William Jolly in October 1928.

The lower floor offered ice cream and refreshments for beach goers and a flight of stairs lead to a dance deck on the beach. The upper level, accessed from Park Parade, was used for private functions and by local organisations such as the Sandgate Yacht Club. This was a cutting edge piece of architecture with modern fittings and equipment and it was heavily used in the inter-war years. No doubt many a moonlit stroll along "lover's walk" began and ended in this building, resulting in weddings on the top floor and later family outings to the sheltered beach between the piers. A local institution, in other words.

Moora Park Kiosk from the Beach. Photo courtesy of John Oxley Library.
But patronage declined in the 40's and by 1974 the neglected and vandalized building was ready for demolition, well before the end of its potential life. So why the sudden downfall?

Back in the 1800's and early 1900's Shorncliffe was one of the few options available for city dwellers seeking seaside recreation. The Brisbane population would migrate en masse to this small strip of sand on hot summer days using the convenient train service. But as automobile ownership spread after the war other locations on the Gold and Sunshine Coasts were preferred by the new generation. Shorncliffe retired to a more dignified and less hectic existence, as we find it today.

Moora Park Kiosk from Park Parade. Photo courtesy of the John Oxley Library.
Next time you pass by, imagine this majestic building on top of the hill, with uninterrupted views across the bay to the islands and beyond. Count Basie and Bing Crosby played by the Sandgate Town Band on balmy summer nights. It must have been a fabulous spot.


Sources
- John Oxley Library
- Brisbane City Council, Bramble Bay Foreshores Conservation Study, 2002
- Brisbane Courier, TROVE historical archives

If anyone has a photo of the kiosk showing the "ladies lavatory" sign please let me know - it would be nice to finally confirm the identity of the rubble. I did however correspond with the Sandgate Historical Society and they shared my assessment of the ruins. For more information on the history of this suburb, check the society's home page or visit the museum: http://www.sandgatemuseum.com.au/

Character Housing & the New Brisbane City Plan


You've probably heard that a new Brisbane City Plan is underway, which includes some changes to the protection of "character" neighborhoods in and around our growing metropolis. The BCC brochures were short on detail so I decided to join one of the "meet a planner" sessions currently underway as part of the consultation process. After a pleasant and informative exchange I came away with a reasonable view, and here's the Executive Summary.

But first - a recap of the current framework. The 2000 city plan protects neighborhoods with pre-1946 houses through Demolition Control Precincts (DCPs), where the removal or significant alterations to a house is assessed according to several criteria, including age and contribution to the streetscape. In other words - some of the houses in these precincts have a limited level of protection, depending on circumstances. New development in these areas is further governed by the Residential Character Code,  requiring new designs to be compatible with surrounding buildings.

To illustrate the application of these codes, let's look at some examples from Auchenflower. The two houses below are within the DCP but only the cottage to the right is protected, based a pre-1946 construction date. The house to the left, a typical post-war conventional, may be removed by the owner. The Council refers mainly to the collection of 1946 aerial photos to identify buildings that existed as of that year.


However, pre-1946 houses within the DCP can be demolished or substantially modified under certain circumstances. In the below pictures, the fabulous little 1800's worker's cottage to the left (on Haig Rd) has been deemed structurally unsound and irreparable, and therefore approved for demolition. This was many months ago and the house still stands - thankfully, but its fate may be sealed. The tragedy/travesty to the right is from Windsor, and illustrates a case where distinguishing features of the original building have been ordered to be preserved. And there it is - a single gable facade, high in the air, waiting for a new box to be tucked to the back. A complete demolition by any reasonable definition but apparently still compliant with code.

                                                                       Photo courtesy of the National Trust
New construction in DCPs is assessed under the Residential Character Code to ensure that designs are compatibile with the surrounding streetscape. In the below examples the house to the left, although built with rendered external walls, has obvious similarities to the original bungalows of the area with an iron roof, open verandas and a protruding gable. External joinery details are heritage-style reproductions. The house to the right has few traditional features - notably weatherboard cladding - but is otherwise contemporary. As for the aesthetic merits of each design, well that's a matter of taste, but both were approved under the code.


So what's changing with the proposed new city plan? The bad-ish news is that there will be no expansion of the DCPs zones - this can be done only through the local neighborhood planning process. The planner I talked to was quite frank about the reason for this - any dabbling in protected zones is politically sensitive. Heaven knows,  the "wreck & flip", mum & dad developers and real estate agents out there may take offense and vote for another, less heritage oriented government.

The former DCPs will be re-named "Neighborhood Character (Demolition)" areas in the new plan, and supplemented with Neighborhood Character (Design) overlays.

Demolition Control Zones around Kedron Brook on Brisbane's North Side. The older suburbs of Windsor, Wilston and Grange (to the right) have a higher proportion of pre-1946 houses than Enoggera (to the left). Click to enlarge.
The new plan makes it easier for owners to move existing character houses within their current plots, allegedly to promote sub-division of land in inner suburbs, increase dwelling density and alleviate fringe sprawl. Good luck on that one, with the current rate of population growth. There are also changes to the protection of some commercial character buildings, specifically the little "corner shops" with awnings across the adjacent sidewalks, that are dotted across our suburbs.

Corner shop with awning, Birdwood Terrace
A major improvement is the increased level of protection of all houses built before 1911 (the current plan protects houses built before 1900). Interim regulations have been pushed through and the protection is already in effect, covering about 400 buildings in the Council area. This is outstanding news as far as I'm concerned.

I was skeptical to the arbitrary pre-1911 cutoff, knowing well the difficulties in pinning down a precise construction date of a century old house. But the BCC heritage unit has done a thorough job using same methods as outlined elsewhere in this blog, using aerial photographs, land and council records, post office directories etc. An impressive undertaking, and highly commended. No doubt there are houses out there that have fallen through the net and should be listed in the pre-1911 register - if you know of any such buildings please contact the heritage unit (current owners of the houses retain the right to opt out).

The highest level of protection is afforded to buildings included in the Queensland and Brisbane City Heritage Registers, for buildings of particular significance or local importance. The heritage register and assessment criteria will not be changed.

So - there it is. Some good news, but still a long way to go. My personal view is that much of our housing stock from the 1910's and 20's represents a high point of Queensland vernacular architecture, and its cultural (and monetary) value will only increase as the years go by. From the 1930's we have inherited a collection of  very distinct styles - Spanish Californian, Functionalist, Art Deco, Old English etc. All of these buildings are irreplaceable and add great character to our suburban landscape. At some point whatever remains of them will be given an appropriate level of protection, and future generations will lament that they weren't protected sooner.